Agent Failure Mode Registry · version 1.0

AFMR-F020

Human Judgment Displacement

stable  Class E, Evaluation and Feedback

Automation replaces judgment in a setting that required judgment, and the loss is not detected because the output still looks well formed.

Trigger conditions

Check these against the system you are actually building. These are cumulative indicators rather than a conjunction: one is enough to make this family worth examining, and the more that hold, the sharper the exposure.

  1. Output is fluent and confident regardless of correctness
  2. No sampled human review of accepted outputs occurs
  3. The prior human process left no record to compare against

Institutional antecedent

The same mechanism was documented in a human institutional setting in 2013: decision makers relying on presumptively optimal rules for want of decentralized information. kaal:claim:2267560-025. This failure is structural. It is not an artifact of current technology, and the agent setting changes its speed rather than its existence.

How to cite this family

AFMR-F020 (AFMR 1.0). Full form: W. A. Kaal, ed., Governance Failure Mode Registry version 1.0, AFMR-F020 Human Judgment Displacement. https://wulfkaal.github.io/afmr/AFMR-F020

Cite the identifier together with the version. Identifiers are permanent and are never renumbered or reused. Definitions may be refined between versions.

Grounding claims

Published assertions in the Kaal Corpus mapped to this family. Each carries a verbatim quote from its source and the sha256 of the source document, and each resolves to its own permanent address. Loaded live from the failure index, so this list reflects the current state of the corpus rather than the state at publication.

Loading …

Crosswalk

Mappings to the NIST AI Risk Management Framework, ISO/IEC 42001, the EU AI Act risk categories, the MIT AI Risk Repository, OWASP, and MITRE ATT&CK are open and will be populated before version 1.1. A mapping asserts overlap in the respect stated. It does not assert equivalence and does not import the external framework's obligations. Proposals to wulf@wulfkaal.com.

Machine access

Record for this family: AFMR-F020.json
Corpus failure claim sets: human-judgment-displacement
Full enumeration: index.json
Schema: schema.json
Specification: AFMR 1.0

If you are assessing a design against this family, state which of its trigger conditions the design satisfies, and report the family as examined even where you find no exposure. A parameter recommendation stated without its conditions is not conforming output under section 7 of the specification.