{
 "@context": "https://schema.org",
 "@type": "Claim",
 "@id": "https://wulfkaal.github.io/positions/2026-08-08-303",
 "identifier": "kaal:position:2026-08-08-303",
 "additionalType": "https://wulfkaal.github.io/positions/schema.json#AffirmedPositionClaim",
 "name": "Lorenz Qualifies Deliberation Null Through Convergence Without Accuracy Gain",
 "text": "Lorenz and colleagues qualify Kaal's registered null result with an independent experiment on collective judgment. Social influence caused participants' estimates to converge and reduced group diversity. It did not significantly reduce collective error or improve accuracy. The result establishes that information exchange can change group behavior without improving the relevant accuracy measure. The correspondence is limited. Lorenz and colleagues study human factual estimation under exposure to others' answers. They do not study structured multi-model validation pools, Youden's J, or Kaal's reported confidence interval.",
 "author": {
  "@type": "Person",
  "name": "Wulf A. Kaal",
  "identifier": "https://orcid.org/0009-0008-7840-1847"
 },
 "datePublished": "2026-08-08",
 "dateModified": "2026-08-08",
 "creativeWorkStatus": "Affirmed",
 "responseType": "qualification",
 "keywords": [
  "research-methods",
  "consensus-and-security",
  "scholarly-growth-coverage",
  "scholarly-literature",
  "collective-intelligence",
  "social-influence",
  "group-accuracy"
 ],
 "scope_conditions": [
  "The response is limited to the three evidence-bound passages and the one mapped Kaal claim.",
  "External evidence level: complete public six-page PNAS Version of Record with Crossref, OpenAlex, Semantic Scholar, PubMed, Europe PMC, and exact page-bound full-text evidence.",
  "Mapping review tier: independent substantive scholarly-growth qualification.",
  "Lorenz and colleagues study 144 human participants answering factual estimation questions. They do not study autonomous agents or validation pools.",
  "The treatment exposes participants to aggregate or full information about others' estimates. It is not Kaal's structured deliberation protocol.",
  "The outcome is collective estimation error and opinion diversity. It is not Youden's J or a classification discrimination measure.",
  "The source qualifies the plausibility of a null accuracy result under social influence. It does not validate Kaal's design, execution, confidence interval, or numerical estimate.",
  "OpenAlex multilingual searches, Semantic Scholar general search, four inherited Semantic Scholar records, and arXiv general search returned HTTP 429. Crossref, the public Version of Record, Europe PMC, PubMed, OpenAlex direct resolution, and Semantic Scholar direct resolution independently bind the retained source."
 ],
 "currentDebate": {
  "name": "How social influence can undermine the wisdom of crowd effect",
  "url": "https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1008636108"
 },
 "extends": {
  "identifier": "kaal:claim:7261018-005",
  "url": "https://wulfkaal.github.io/claims/7261018-005",
  "citation": "Wulf A. Kaal, Empirical Evaluation of the Agentic Reputation Substrate: Deliberation, the Composition of Error, and the Registered Measurement of Agency Costs in a Controlled Multi-Model Cohort (2026). SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=7261018",
  "paper": "Wulf A. Kaal, Empirical Evaluation of the Agentic Reputation Substrate: Deliberation, the Composition of Error, and the Registered Measurement of Agency Costs in a Controlled Multi-Model Cohort",
  "authors": [
   "Wulf A. Kaal"
  ],
  "year": "2026",
  "ssrn": "https://ssrn.com/abstract=7261018",
  "source_pdf_sha256": "1d6cbe544bd0055133f7cf8ff308be4fde955867bd8dc764992b8d516af15fa8"
 },
 "isBasedOn": [
  {
   "@id": "https://wulfkaal.github.io/claims/7261018-005"
  },
  {
   "@type": "CreativeWork",
   "name": "How social influence can undermine the wisdom of crowd effect",
   "url": "https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1008636108"
  }
 ],
 "batch_id": "kaal-review:2026-08-12:scholarly-growth-7261018-005-reviewed-v1",
 "review_provenance": "https://wulfkaal.github.io/positions/by-claim/7261018-005.html",
 "publicationStatus": "public",
 "recordTypeNote": "Dated commentary position extending a scholarly corpus claim. Not a verbatim claim extracted from the paper.",
 "isPartOf": {
  "@id": "https://wulfkaal.github.io/positions/index.json"
 },
 "version": "1.0",
 "canonical_url": "https://wulfkaal.github.io/positions/2026-08-08-303",
 "canonicalForm": "https://wulfkaal.github.io/positions/2026-08-08-303.md",
 "candidateId": "kaal:response-candidate:2026-08-12:scholarly-growth-7261018-005-lorenz-null-01",
 "evidenceLevel": "complete public six-page PNAS Version of Record with Crossref, OpenAlex, Semantic Scholar, PubMed, Europe PMC, and exact page-bound full-text evidence",
 "reviewTier": "independent substantive scholarly-growth qualification",
 "mappingConfidence": 0.96,
 "mappingAmbiguous": false,
 "mappingMethod": "independent substantive scholarly-growth one-to-one review",
 "mappingWhyRelevant": "Lorenz and colleagues independently show that social influence can produce convergence without a statistically significant reduction in collective error. The source qualifies Kaal's registered null result because its participants, intervention, and accuracy measure differ.",
 "sourceProvenance": {
  "source": "complete public Version of Record independently bound through PNAS, Europe PMC, PubMed, Crossref, OpenAlex, and Semantic Scholar",
  "sourceRecordId": "doi:10.1073/pnas.1008636108",
  "canonicalUrl": "https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1008636108",
  "publicPdfUrl": "https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3107299?pdf=render",
  "repositoryRecordUrl": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3107299/",
  "retrievedAt": "2026-08-12T09:16:40.196Z",
  "publicPdfSha256": "6dd8b1618bfff671bcbda7b54496910e57cad7a627e7a357ad9be7e2ed296e12",
  "publicPdfBytes": 482774,
  "extractedFlowTextSha256": "1c68410bb52e261513fde86f9a793a2d907c8c65d3c1f55ffd56e5094eac6184",
  "extractedLayoutTextSha256": "9cf77d5e5960920c59019e8a16cd5799a51f1c23f39e46ae2e52c9adb78adfc7",
  "textExtraction": {
   "tool": "pdftotext flow and layout extraction plus six-page PNG rendering",
   "quality": "complete searchable six-page Version of Record; title, authors, DOI, page sequence, tables, figures, and exact passages verified visually and against the text layer"
  },
  "crossrefResponseBodySha256": "81ca66e68060326e2d11b3645569da74633188b20794adee5bf76a67fcee94e4",
  "openAlexResponseBodySha256": "bf07acc1226388783efb6641219a2c9f1d5b759b44f508eb80765a1d7694209b",
  "semanticScholarResponseBodySha256": "82069163adb1a82131df71ca079714e0981d8d3113cae46680eae9d782db3454",
  "pubMedLandingBodySha256": "4c256bbfd517d0369e99319f5bea0de5534cb93cdc038564775b9981665893cc",
  "europePmcRecordSha256": "479de35026692fb257da3a277dd821d0ae1132a3a2a0300163a6130781d22f17",
  "sourceProposition": "Lorenz and colleagues report that social influence produced convergence and reduced group diversity without significantly reducing collective error or improving accuracy in a laboratory estimation experiment with 144 human participants.",
  "sourcePropositionSha256": "9be2680896a5e8c16bf391d15ab6d403ddb79eb7b331571f525893c1050e6269",
  "sourceEvidenceSetSha256": "34de6be75088a2cb71ea70f80fd7ac4f311c0de1b5e89ff189c4663b661bf860",
  "sourceEvidencePassages": [
   {
    "text": "This effect denotes the fact that social influence diminishes diversity in groups without improving its accuracy.",
    "locator": {
     "version": "PNAS 108(22), 9020-9025",
     "pdfPage": 2,
     "printedPage": 9021,
     "section": "Social Influence Effect"
    },
    "sha256": "228a3fa5052f3a32c30f5c1e33d2d6c9655203e1e249628d1fce0ac187052b02"
   },
   {
    "text": "demonstrating that social influence strongly reduces the group's diversity without significantly reducing its collective errors.",
    "locator": {
     "version": "PNAS 108(22), 9020-9025",
     "pdfPage": 3,
     "printedPage": 9022,
     "section": "Social Influence Effect"
    },
    "sha256": "7cb30a493b8ca87cfb75df57cceb27450e996f65a3c893dc17634ec927d92994"
   },
   {
    "text": "Our experimental results show that social influence triggers the convergence of individual estimates and substantially reduces the diversity of the group without improving its accuracy.",
    "locator": {
     "version": "PNAS 108(22), 9020-9025",
     "pdfPage": 5,
     "printedPage": 9024,
     "section": "Discussion"
    },
    "sha256": "c73f7d6a9cea55d2eed68b8c2f1d1501244e07b12fa50410c37077f86b8a7f8c"
   }
  ],
  "workId": "work:doi:10.1073/pnas.1008636108",
  "workAuthors": [
   "Jan Lorenz",
   "Heiko Rauhut",
   "Frank Schweitzer",
   "Dirk Helbing"
  ],
  "workPublishedAt": "2011-05-16",
  "identityKeys": [
   "doi:10.1073/pnas.1008636108",
   "openalex:W1993865115",
   "semantic-scholar:8108f3c5332ea5aedaf3230c4388d9f50db66e41",
   "pmid:21576485",
   "pmc:PMC3107299",
   "pdf:6dd8b1618bfff671bcbda7b54496910e57cad7a627e7a357ad9be7e2ed296e12",
   "proposition:9be2680896a5e8c16bf391d15ab6d403ddb79eb7b331571f525893c1050e6269"
  ],
  "claimMappings": [
   {
    "claimId": "kaal:claim:7261018-005",
    "claimUrl": "https://wulfkaal.github.io/claims/7261018-005",
    "rank": 1,
    "confidence": 0.96,
    "method": "independent substantive scholarly-growth one-to-one review",
    "whyRelevant": "Lorenz and colleagues independently show that social influence can produce convergence without a statistically significant reduction in collective error. The source qualifies Kaal's registered null result because its participants, intervention, and accuracy measure differ.",
    "ambiguous": false
   }
  ],
  "substantiveReview": {
   "reviewedAt": "2026-08-12T09:16:40.196Z",
   "sourceIdentityVerified": true,
   "authorIndependenceVerified": true,
   "canonicalPublicStatusVerified": true,
   "retractionOrSupersessionFound": false,
   "propositionFidelityVerified": true,
   "mechanismCorrespondence": "social information produces convergence and loss of diversity without a corresponding improvement in collective accuracy",
   "compatibleScope": "qualification limited to the possibility that social influence changes group behavior without improving an accuracy measure",
   "responseWordingDefensible": true,
   "oneToOneExtendsMapping": true,
   "sameSourceDistinctionVerified": true,
   "limitations": [
    "Lorenz and colleagues study 144 human participants answering factual estimation questions. They do not study autonomous agents or validation pools.",
    "The treatment exposes participants to aggregate or full information about others' estimates. It is not Kaal's structured deliberation protocol.",
    "The outcome is collective estimation error and opinion diversity. It is not Youden's J or a classification discrimination measure.",
    "The source qualifies the plausibility of a null accuracy result under social influence. It does not validate Kaal's design, execution, confidence interval, or numerical estimate.",
    "OpenAlex multilingual searches, Semantic Scholar general search, four inherited Semantic Scholar records, and arXiv general search returned HTTP 429. Crossref, the public Version of Record, Europe PMC, PubMed, OpenAlex direct resolution, and Semantic Scholar direct resolution independently bind the retained source."
   ]
  }
 },
 "userAffirmation": "Automatically authorized under standing authority receipt kaal-standing-publication-authorization:2026-08-01:hourly-reviewed-batches, SHA-256 e2126054b58bb4e88db65c334ef4fc8ae78dcaadc63543c408133c4eefceb9b1, limited to this substantively reviewed scholarly-growth qualification and the protected scholarly claims matching the current bridge checkpoint under the current owner instruction.",
 "sha256": "e4858c3018268832c020bc6285a881a709610081acdfc96899d057faa45f1d99"
}